I LOVE this ring. I got it in the Rose Gold fill. The Garnet is more red and you can see through it (Phone camera sucks). The way the sun shines through it is GORGEOUS!
Few flaws: Two stones on one side have shifted and become sunken/crooked in their setting. And there is a small chip at the base of the main setting. Neither of these are noticeable to other people!
This is an absolutely beautiful ring, I am constantly staring at it. Ive gotten lots of compliments on it as well. I have worn it for a little over a week and no color has come off (I do remove it when washing my hands).
I also got a stacking band for it and they go great together! The stones on the stacking ring are smaller, as stated in their description. The stacking ring has zero visible flaws and is perfect solo or paired with another ring.